Pale Carnations: Complete CG Unlock & All Endings Walkthrough Guide

1. Initial Setup & First Save Points

1. For the four opening questions, directly choose: 3 > 2 > 2 > 2
   2. Match his enthusiasm > Sooth > To a limited extent > Praise her cooking > Talk about her job > Mention her date > Tell her it's no big deal > Chat about recent movies > Excuse yourself to the bathroom
   3. For text message, choose: Politely decline
   4. Let Ian finish > Flirt with her > For text, choose: It went okay > For text, choose: I'm here > Shake his hand > Compliment her name > My good friend

You MUST save here: SAVE1—this file will be loaded multiple times later, don't forget it.

5. Continue with: Tell her she can join > Text message: I'm in > Tight hug > Thank him with a joke > Thank him > Keep choosing randomly > Take the money > Show respect by using her surname > Comfort > Continue > Look > What does this mean > Joke > Show interest in her work

Save here: SAVE2—another core save point, remember it.

2. Correct Way to Progress Early Bar Story

1. Click Felicia to glance, then return via bottom-left
   2. Click Mina to trigger scene
   3. Click bottom-left to return to bar area
   4. Click bar, then bartender, order a Cherry Bomb
   5. Click buddy Killian—this guy truly lives up to his name
   6. Pick first option
   7. Click stairs, choose Mina—this scene cracked me up
   8. Click Felicia, choose "I want to check on Mina again"
   9. Click Mina, choose "Yeah, why not"
   10. Click bottom-left to dance floor, click Mina
   11. Tell her the truth—just throw your buddy under the bus
   12. Click bottom-left to return, then click Mina again
   13. Help Mina > Tell him to get lost > Step forward
   14. Let her know it's cool > Look forward to it > You did great, relax
   15. Tell her your birthday > Kiss her Unlock Mina Recollection 01

Put on a show > I don't want to... > Do it yourself > Accept Felicia > Indulge > Demand some privacy > I want to > Throat > Tell her Unlock Felicia Recollection 03 > Ask him what this is about > Sorry to keep her waiting > Look directly > Fuck you > Text: Don't sweat it > Shout to her > Shake hands > State the facts > Pull it out > Choose Lucy Unlock MISC01, same as Veronica01—won't mention duplicates for other characters > Invite her for coffee > Choose both once each > Tell her she's right > What's going on? > I'm at least curious > Of course > Thanks for the advice Unlock MISC02 > Ask about Veronica > Turn around > Choose the latter Unlock Veronica Recollection 02 > Veronica wins Unlock Veronica Recollection 03 > Agree with him Unlock Veronica Recollection 04 > Comfortingly > Too late now, double down > Say nothing > Absolutely not Unlock MISC04 > Very excited Unlock Catherine Recollection 04

Save here: SAVE3—another key save file.

Follow Hannah > Of course > Ass > Is taking advantage of being in... > Ask if she wants to come in. So far all menu items are unlocked, most importantly STATISTICS—this lets you check each character's attributes. Very important—check it yourself if you can't remember.

3. Mid-Game Story Progression & Attribute Building

1. Flatly deny > Don't try... > Praise everything—this gives the most attribute points

Save before choosing: SAVE4

2. Rosalind cooperation > The lead girl? > Ask what's the rush > Directly switch to more... > Tell her to take it out > Tell her they're not wrong > Choose randomly Unlock Rosalind Recollection 02

3. Agree to help Hannah > Wish them fun > Half-truth > Agree to accompany Mina > Say what you're thinking > Talk freely about the dress > Tell her it will leave an impression > Look > Keep looking, no reason not to since it doesn't reduce stats > Cute route > Felicia > Accept dinner invitation > Thank Mina for caring > Put hand on > Ask how she knows > Tell her to use your name > Express feelings > Tell her you accept the deal—choose this for a future event > Choose randomly > Still random > Ask if she's really okay > Pick first option > Inside > Random Unlock Rosalind Recollection 03

4. Text: second option > Tell him you like it here > Thanks for the kind offer > Play along > Show me more > Tell a joke > Pull closer > Choose nose > Acknowledge her point Unlock Felicia Recollection 06

5. Greet the boss > Tell him you're trustworthy > Tell Hannah they're impressive > Compliment Hannah's tattoo > Talk about Hannah's motorcycle > Admire her resilience > Tell her you're just learning > Forget it, have fun in the pool > Tell Catherine I was already planning to > Tell Catherine you really don't want to > Invite Mina to the gym > Tell her you want to get healthier > Change topic by apologizing > Ask for help > Be honest with them > Let her prove herself > Tease Ian about his childhood > Text back "you're a good girl" Unlock Rosalind Recollection 04

4. Club Competition 3-Round Guaranteed Win Method

1. Click everyone clickable > Click top-left to explore > Bar > Click Hannah > Tell her you're sorry... > Click everything, don't forget the professor on the sofa
   2. Top-left explore > Security > Tell Warren this place is interesting
   3. Top-left explore > Hallway > Click Hannah or security guard > Stay professional > Stay calm...
   4. Top-left explore > Changing room > Watch silently > Touch... > Tell her not to get cocky Unlock Veronica Recollection 08
   5. Top-left explore > Bar > Click everything clickable
   6. Top-left explore > Security room > Computer > Take a look
   7. Top-left explore > VIP lounge > Click middle > Yes, continue > Help Veronica... > Follow Catherine's example > Thank her for this opportunity

Save before choosing: SAVE5—this is crucial. You need to run this three times minimum to unlock all recollections. Each character must win once and lose once.

First run: Champion Rosalind, Runner-up Felicia, Loser Veronica
   Second run: Champion Felicia, Runner-up Veronica, Loser Rosalind
   Third run: Champion Veronica, Runner-up Rosalind, Loser Felicia

1. First run, choose: Likes gentle, obedient > Feels cared for > Tell her she did it right > Use words to motivate... > Tell her to continue > Tease a little > Tell her it's not good enough > Continue intensely > Tell her you're performing your best > On the cheek Unlock Felicia Recollection 07 > Yes stand up > Worshipped > Demand she speed up Unlock Rosalind Recollection 05 > Make sure she's okay > Pat her Unlock Veronica Recollection 09 > Tell buddy to stop being an ass > Two minimum power settings Unlock Veronica Recollection 10

2. Save before choosing: SAVE6, then sneak out to find Hannah

5. Post-Competition Story & Key Choices

1. Yes, because you have morbid curiosity > I've never used a vacuum... > I've never given the same.... Pick this to unlock MISC06
   2. Let the woman stall > I've never hit on someone during a date > Kiss her > Tell her you only care about being with her Unlock Hannah Recollection 02
   3. Confront angrily > Do your own thing > Slightly exceed Unlock Veronica Recollection 13
   4. Enthusiastic self-introduction > Look at every photo > Click top-right to continue > Point to the family photo > Choose randomly until you stop discussing photos > Tease her, you like her blonde hair > Stare > Stand up to emphasize > One hand... > Turn around to drive them away > Lean forward in seat, watching > Rest chin on hand, look into eyes > Speak from the heart > Grab... while saying next line > Add your own performance > Mina is waiting, kiss Unlock Mina Recollection 04
   5. Accept the gift > You want to see Harper's face for this > Explain in very detailed terms what's about to happen > Harper says it's uncle > Take the bait Unlock MISC07
   6. This is the condition, now do as she says > Choose randomly > Take the lead to turn the tables Unlock Catherine Recollection 10

1. Call Veronica > Ask if everything's okay > Stay friendly, like it's business > Tell her you're just admiring her behind > Share your honest thoughts > Tell her.... > Try warming up before remaining shoot > Use intimate... > Choose randomly > Use your own tools > Stop upsetting Veronica > Grab Veronica > Insist she does this job > Martial artist... > Pick first option > Encourage Unlock Veronica Recollections 14, 15, 16

2. Kiss > Tell her this is part of the deal > Tease him first > Bring this to the tunnel > Help jog her memory > Kiss > Tell her you don't mind... > Cooperate with creativity and passion > Find a new angle > Resist as long as possible Unlock Rosalind Recollections 10, 11, 12

3. Sleep on the sofa Unlock Hannah Recollection 03
   4. Hold tight > Emphasize the importance of money Unlock Hannah Recollections 04, 05, MISC08

5. Be honest > Starting here, Mina's attributes are already high, so choices don't matter much. Try to gently ease her concerns > Pat her head > Ask about her work situation > Convey your personal experience on this matter > Don't focus on negatives > Cheer her up > Tell her she's doing well at work

6. Felicia Exclusive Story Route

1. Must greet Felicia first > Move in for a hug > Tell a joke > Tell her to take a deep breath > Now's the time to push it Unlock Felicia Recollection 12

2. Use it to secretly... during the shoot > Jump to medium intensity > Reconciling with his client is this young agent's job > Turn to Felicia > Continue, see where this leads > Crank it to max > Challenge her > Grab Felicia > Fulfill her dreams (picking the other option here gives this event's alternate animation, which you can try in Recollections) > Tease her > Make fire in a different way > Enjoy more Unlock Felicia Recollections 13, 14, 15

3. Remind her, but you believe she can do it

I recommend saving here: SAVE7, because this choice affects later story. First two options change the relationship to being kept, third option raises dual attributes but relationship stays the same. I picked the third.

4. Call your buddy

7. Late-Game Complex Plot Handling

1. Long story sequence: Tell her Veronica insists on closing the gym > Click security guard > Go to bar > Click boss > Try viewing it as work > Would rather get help from others > Click Dahlia > Keep clicking Dahlia > Go to security room > Go to VIP lounge > Talk to Sophia > Go to changing room > Click buddy's group > Tell him about Rosalind's problem

2. Okay, you'll bring it up to Rosalind MUST choose this—relates to unlocking a later recollection > Click Harper > Go to VIP lounge > Click professor > Click Albert

Save here: SAVE8

3. Rosaline > Fair play > Ranged attack > Charge down, grab him > Mash the special button... > Pick first option, head pat > Cross the line > Choose freely from here Unlock Mina Recollection 05

4. Kiss—in accepting this, Mina's attributes are maxed and you're lovers > Let her handle it at her own pace > Call Hannah

5. When options appear, save SAVE9. Now start recollection cleanup—many remain locked:

8. Full Recollection Recovery Plan

Load: SAVE1
   1. Take advantage > Choose freely from here Unlock Rosalind Recollection 01

Load: SAVE2
   1. Click Felicia > Get a Cherry Bomb from bartender > Return to Felicia > I don't see the harm > Suggest we get one > I'll show her enthusiasm > Monet > Go for it > Choose freely from here, two animations available to try in Recollections Unlock Felicia Recollection 01

Load: SAVE2
   1. Click Felicia > Get Cherry Bomb from bartender > Click buddy, good plan > Return to Felicia > I want to check on Mina again > Click Mina > Sure, but let me invite Felicia first > Click Felicia > Go to dance floor, click Mina > Go to bar, ask buddy for help > Let her go > Look forward to it > You did great, let them relax > Tell birthday > Let her ask Felicia Unlock Mina Recollection 01
   2. I couldn't possibly... > Accept advance payment > Indulge > Ask if he wants to join Unlock Felicia Recollection 04

9. Late-Game Branching & Endings

Load: SAVE3
   1. This is troublesome—requires replaying a long segment. I'm opening this save because my main route lacked much Catherine affection, just in case.
   2. Help Mrs. Pullman to her office > Bring up going outside proactively > Enjoyed it more than I imagined > Round 3: Veronica & you > Many options are random from here, until collaboration shoot—still pick Rosalind > Continue randomly until 5 options appear, pick 234 > Reject Hannah's party > Wish them fun > Then hold CTRL and choose randomly, reject all invitations until knocking option appears > Wait a moment, eavesdrop first Unlock Catherine Recollection 05

Load: SAVE4
   1. Cooperate with Felicia > Choose freely Unlock Felicia Recollection 05

Load: SAVE4
   1. Cooperate with Veronica > Still choose freely Unlock Veronica Recollection 06

Load: SAVE5
   1. Pick first > Pick first again > Tell her she did it right > Shut up > Wait for her to recover > Put directly into waiting... > Continue... > Ignore him > That could be misunderstood > Yes, tell her > Tortured > Demand she speed up > For Veronica pick second > Tell buddy to be a good person Unlock Rosalind Recollection 06
   2. Remote both set to low > Stay and watch > Join Unlock Rosalind Recollection 08

Load: SAVE5
   1. A considerate one > Sadistic > Tell her she did it right > Shut up > Wait for her to recover > Put directly into waiting... > Continue... > Ignore him > That could be misunderstood > Yes, tell her > Worshipped > Demand she speed up > For Veronica pick second > Tell buddy to be a good person Unlock Felicia Recollection 09
   2. Remote both set to low > Stay and watch > Join Unlock Felicia Recollection 10

Load: SAVE6
   1. Stay and watch Unlock Veronica Recollection 12

Now all previous recollections are recovered. Continue the story:

Load: SAVE9
   1. Give some affirmation > ????? > Show your true self > Go all out Unlock Rosalind Recollections 14, 15
   2. At club, click Rosaline first > Show Rosaline's sensitivity Unlock Rosalind Recollection 16
   3. Click Felicia's side > Feel proud, take it out Unlock Felicia Recollection 16
   4. Click Jacob > Use your position to help Jacob > Click top-left explore > BAR > Talk to everyone except Harper's group on sofa first > Then click Harper > Go over and say hi > Have him talk about himself and his life's successes Unlock MISC09
   5. Go to August's room to chat > Go to BAR, talk to those on sofa > Go to security room, chat with Jacob to learn rock room has situation > Go to rock music room > Let them finish while appreciating Unlock MISC10
   6. Go to pool > Go to VIP lounge > Talk to those on sofa first > Then click bartender buddy's side > Take more direct approach to get doctor off Emma > Go to velvet room > Click everyone except Catherine's group first > Finally click Catherine > Go over there > Light slap won't hurt > Put on a wonderful show for the audience Unlock Veronica Recollection 18
   7. Try to comfort her > Use gentle method > Pinch > Take sensual approach to get answers > Felicia can accept this > Pick first, have a taste Unlock Felicia Recollection 17
   8. Okay, if your anonymity is guaranteed > Greet enthusiastically... > Take creative initiative > Encourage with kisses > Stay calm > Pick first Unlock Rosalind Recollection 17 > Save: SAVE10

9. Visit Mina > Choose randomly Unlock Mina Recollection 06 > Be honest with her > Ian is an independent individual > Be frank and honest with your friend > Nun sounds good > Choose randomly > Ignore it, focus your attention on Hana > Kiss > Grab Hannah's hand > Take more open approach > Live in the moment... Unlock Hannah Recollection 07
   10. Interrupt and break tension > Change topic > Choose randomly > Put hand on.... Unlock Hannah Recollection 08
   11. You both will forget your anxiety > Stay calm, reassure her > Sweet talk her > Flip the script, compliment > Shoot Unlock Hannah Recollection 09
   12. Promise to be by Hannah's side Unlock Hannah Recollection 10 > Encourage her despite... > Save here SAVE11—this determines whether you become girlfriend or just playmate

Load SAVE10
   1. Ask Catherine for advice > After story Unlock Catherine Recollection 14

Load SAVE11
   1. I tentatively picked second—playmate, because I already have Mina > I like how you smell (other choices probably don't matter since affection is maxed) > Give yourself a shock... > Choosing go all out here reduces Rosalind affection by 2, adds Catherine 1. I chose go all out > Don't hold back > First option reduces Felicia 3, adds Catherine 1 affection & 2 trust; second adds Felicia 2 affection, reduces Catherine affection & trust. I picked first Unlock Catherine Recollection 15
   2. Shock Mrs. Pullman > Hold her hand > Leg > Put her hand back > Since we can't see Sophia's data, I still picked first, can add Catherine trust Unlock four shared recollections
   3. Mention Harper & Lucy > Kiss her forehead Important reminder: An unresolved Mina recollection 08 requires loading SAVE8, after choosing Rosalind, post-arcade with Mina & her brother at her home you must pick "don't cross the line", and not become lovers with Hannah to trigger. Since it's long, I won't detail it—this CG isn't that great anyway > Be direct > Have her turn around > Choose randomly > Speed up > Then all random Unlock Mina Recollections 09, MISC15
   4. Accuse him > Press for more > It's just being cautious > Show me > Agree with him... > Friendly... > There's an attraction you can't deny > Save: SAVE12 > You have other ways to spend sleepless nights > Call Hannah > You missed her voice > Then all random After story unlocks Hannah Recollection 11

5. After mom story pick interesting > Call Rosalind > Call Felicia > You're calling as her friend > Apologize > Call Veronica > Possible > Save: SAVE13 > Since Rosalind's affection is too low and there's a CG timing conflict, main route won't choose drinking with Veronica > Ask if Rosalind's okay > Stand firm > Sit down > Suggest simple and clear solution > Do something good for Rosalind > Really happy to have a roommate again > Ignore your thoughts Unlock Rosalind Recollection 23
   6. Prove it > Choose randomly Unlock Hannah Recollection 12
   7. You still have room to grow > Mention Albert came by the other day > This is our intel > Agree insisting on this is wrong > Move before he does This plot segment appears because you had buddy help Rosalind pay back money earlier in my guide
   8. Say name directly > Cheer her up > Pick first > You're also happy to be back... > Give him high five Unlock Rosalind Recollection 24
   9. Greet Felicia warmly > Don't let her retreat > Fight for more > Can I buy you a drink > Put hand on her waist > Hand kiss > Interrupt > Comfort from behind > Talk about their history > Tease bluntly > Requires max Felicia affection at this point > The psychology of wanting to go out... > Save: SAVE14 > Give her a little touch > Ask how she's been > Ask if Eric's treating her well tonight > You know, but she shouldn't worry > Find excuse to leave... > Return to Felicia > Your hands uncontrollably... > Before that > Warn her about Warren > Pretend there's something on her face > Suggest she talk to Dennis > Save: SAVE15 > More the merrier, I'm doing threesome route > Enough Unlock Mina Recollection 10

Version 4.4 main story ends here, you can save SAVE16. Now we begin final recollection cleanup:

Load SAVE12
   1. You do enjoy watching > Choose randomly Unlock MISC16

Load SAVE13
   1. Invite her for a drink tonight > Choose randomly until drinking with Veronica > Dance? > Tell her she looks beautiful too > Save: SAVE17 > Let go of all reservations, invite her to dance Unlock Veronica Recollection 24 > You're drunk, just be honest > Go for it Unlock Veronica Recollection 25 > Choose randomly > Keep worshipping > Random > Whatever you like > Random since it's a side route anyway > Random Unlock Veronica Recollection 26

load SAVE17
   1. Help Veronica play matchmaker > Insist on the bet > Be bold... > Let her stay a while Unlock MISC17 > Keep choosing randomly until before seeing Felicia Unlock Veronica Recollection 27

Load SAVE14
   1. Give her a little touch > Ask how she's been > Ask if Eric's treating her well tonight > You know, but she shouldn't worry > Find excuse to leave... > As always, curiosity wins > Save him trouble, say hello > Random > You want to figure out... > Suggest she talk to Dennis while you go find Lucy > Honestly express... > Appeal to empathy > Let her get close Unlock MISC18

Load SAVE14 again
   1. Ask your suspicions directly > Tell her she looks good tonight > Ask about her and Harper > Unfortunately, that's a risk she has to bear > Before you go, you must ask one more time > As always, curiosity wins > Suggest she talk to Dennis while you go find Lucy > Play with fear > Hint you should have good relationship > Pull close and remind > Push further Unlock MISC19

Load SAVE15
   1. You really just want to be alone with Felicia > You won't encounter... again > You are > Random > Feel romantic Unlock Felicia Recollection 24

Alright, all version 4.4 recollections are now collected. The Carnation guide was really difficult to make, took me two full nights. I feel my preference is shifting more toward Felicia now—limitless charm. The author's clothing design and selection truly has great taste. Looking forward to future story developments!